As a travel writer at Wirecutter, I’ve connected with many frequent fliers, including airline staff and even celebrities like Conan O’Brien. One recurring theme in our discussions is the debate between checking bags and carrying on. Many seasoned travelers advocate for the simplicity and efficiency of carry-ons to avoid lost luggage and promote minimal packing. “You’ll feel happier if you bring less,” advised Elaine Glusac, a columnist for The New York Times.
However, when I spoke with our own travel experts at Wirecutter, they leaned heavily towards checking bags, claiming the push for carry-ons is somewhat overrated. Here’s why they suggest you might want to consider checking your luggage instead.
The Perks of Checking a Bag
-
No Overhead Bin Rivalry: With overhead space becoming increasingly rare due to larger carry-ons, waiting for boarding can be stressful. Checked bags let you bypass the anxious scramble for storage space and the ensuing chaos in the aisle.
-
Liberty at the Airport: Checking your bag frees you from dragging luggage around. Whether you have extra time at the airport or are transitioning between flights, checking your bag allows you to relax. Writer Trey French highlights how it’s liberating, stating it enables him to enjoy amenities at the airport without the hassle of carrying a bag.
-
Back Health: Spine health experts recommend checking bags to prevent injuries caused by lifting heavy carry-ons awkwardly. Lifting a heavy bag can lead to discomfort or injury, especially if it’s overpacked.
-
Pack Without Regret: When you check a bag, you’re free to bring full-size toiletries and even extra outfits for varying situations. This eliminates the guilt sometimes associated with overpacking and allows you more flexibility for your trips.
-
The Risk of Losing Luggage is Low: Despite the fears surrounding checked baggage, statistics reveal that the chances of losing luggage are minimal—less than 1% according to recent reports. If your bag does get lost, it’s often returned within days.
The Compelling Arguments for Carry-On
Even the staunchest proponents of checking luggage acknowledge valid reasons to go carry-on when it suits your itinerary. Carrying on can save you money, as checked bags often incur fees ranging from $30 and up. It can also save time, especially at busier airports where baggage claim waits can stretch on.
Moreover, for those traveling with valuable items, a carry-on ensures they stay close at hand. Similarly, on trips with tight connections or international flights, carrying on can mitigate the risk of lost baggage.
Make the Choice That Fits You
Ultimately, the decision between checked baggage and carry-ons depends on individual travel preferences and circumstances. Our experts at Wirecutter advocate for personalizing your approach rather than adhering rigidly to a single method. Whether you’re all for checking bags or firmly on Team Carry-On, the key is to choose what works best for you, ensuring a more relaxed travel experience.